logicsrc/docs/openswarm.md
Anthony Ettinger cb5f09b216 Add pay2seed to the OpenSwarm family: consent at upload and a paid seed market
OpenSwarm pays a seeder per verified piece served, and nothing pays anyone
to stay. An archive, a backup, a dataset waiting for its buyer or a
podcast's back catalogue earns nothing the month nobody downloads it, so
it dies the way every swarm always has. And nothing in BitTorrent says who
put a swarm there or whether they were allowed to, which is why a seeder
is presumed to be doing something wrong.

pay2seed is the member document for both halves. An attestation, signed
at upload with a fixed basis (own, licensed, open-license, public-domain,
personal) and a notice endpoint, is what a hub requires before it will
list anything; public claims get a claim window and a standing, and a
notice voids them. An offer escrows a budget at an ippay hub for a swarm,
public or private, to be held by M seeders for N days at a price per
GiB-month, bought over x402 exactly as a pass is. Seeders take leases,
prove each period by storage challenge or by a probe over the ordinary
wire, and are paid through the payee they already have. Public feeds ride
on ipdb; ipfile.pin on c0mpute is the same offer on the auction.

Also: the family table, stack diagram and registry rows; the ip seed
command group; PRD 0006; the protocol row on /openswarm.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.1 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SKAohrRkqLKVQL2cGCAkR5
2026-09-05 23:54:30 +00:00

11 KiB

OpenSwarm

Status: 0.1 draft. No reference implementation yet; see "What already exists" below.

Slug: openswarm

OpenSwarm is a LogicSRC OpenSpec family for paid, encrypted, peer-to-peer distribution of files and media. It is an add-on to BitTorrent, not a new transport. A swarm carries ciphertext, the tracker and the DHT learn nothing about the content, every peer that serves a verified piece gets paid for it, and the same swarm primitives carry files, audio, video, live streams and the catalogue that describes them.

It exists because BitTorrent solved distribution and never solved the two things that keep it from being a product: nobody is paid to seed, and nothing in it is private. Every Profullstack media property (bittorrented.com, tipoffwatch, genrewatch, p0dcasters) has rebuilt the same paid-access layer on top of central HTTP proxies because the swarm could not carry the payment.

Working name during design was "IPMedia". The family is called OpenSwarm because the swarm is the one object every member shares, because "media" undersells ipfile and ipdb, and because "IP media" reads as IPTV, which is a different product. The member protocols keep their ip names.

The family

Protocol One line Document
Core Records, identifiers, keys, signatures, transports, discovery, events spec.md
ipfile Paid, encrypted file swarms as BitTorrent extension messages ipfile.md
ippay Passes and vouchers: how a leecher pays and a seeder is paid, over x402 and CoinPay ippay.md
ipdb A replicated, append-only catalogue of manifests and metadata, discoverable over the DHT ipdb.md
ipaudio Audio releases and tracks on ipfile swarms: renditions, seek tables, gapless, royalties ipaudio.md
ipvideo Video on demand on ipfile swarms: CMAF renditions, segment index, subtitles, thumbnails ipvideo.md
iplive Live streams: segment fan-out over peers, paid relays, backpressure iplive.md
ipname How a Moshpit name resolves to a publisher key and a catalogue ipname.md
pay2seed Consent at upload, seed offers with escrowed budgets, leases, proof of seeding, the seed market pay2seed.md

Supporting documents:

How the pieces stack

  +---------------------------------------------------------------+
  |  ipaudio      ipvideo      iplive         ipdb (catalogue)    |
  |  releases     titles       channels       feeds, entries      |
  +---------------------------------------------------------------+
  |  pay2seed: attestation, offers, leases, challenges, market    |
  +---------------------------------------------------------------+
  |  ipfile: manifest, per-file key pair, encrypted pieces,       |
  |          key grants, credit window, vouchers per served piece |
  +-------------------------------+-------------------------------+
  |  ippay: passes and vouchers   |  ipname: Moshpit name -> key  |
  |  x402 purchase, CoinPay hub   |  and catalogue                |
  +-------------------------------+-------------------------------+
  |  BitTorrent wire (BEP 3) + extension protocol (BEP 10)        |
  |  DHT (BEP 5, 44, 46), trackers, WebRTC peers (WebTorrent),    |
  |  webseeds (BEP 19), optional Moshpit MTP/1 tunnel             |
  +---------------------------------------------------------------+

Reading it upward: a video title is a set of ipfile swarms plus an index. An ipfile swarm is an ordinary hybrid v1/v2 torrent whose payload is ciphertext. Payment and key delivery ride on BEP 10 extension messages that a vanilla client never sees. The catalogue that says what a swarm contains is itself replicated as ipfile swarms and pointed at from the DHT.

Reuse is the default posture

Every building block is specified once, with a stable interface, and reused:

  • Chunking and hashing are BitTorrent v2 (BEP 52): 16 KiB blocks, SHA-256 merkle trees, power-of-two piece lengths. ipaudio, ipvideo and iplive do not define their own.
  • Manifests are one record shape (core §3) with a type. A track, a title and a channel are records that reference ipfile manifests.
  • Keys are one identity model (core §4). A publisher key is reused for every file that publisher adds; per-file keys are derived from it and can be recovered from it. A fresh unrelated pair is minted only on request.
  • Swarm encryption is ipfile's AES-256-CTR over pieces, keyed per file. Audio and video renditions are encrypted the same way, by being files.
  • Payment is ippay's pass and voucher pair. A relay serving live segments is paid with the same voucher a seeder gets for a piece.
  • Relay is one role. A c0mpute node that relays iplive segments uses the same credit window and the same voucher as a seeder.

A member protocol that needs something the core lacks adds a record type or an extension message. It does not redefine a primitive.

How c0mpute.com nodes participate

A c0mpute node already advertises roles (storage, transcode, gateway, verifier) and takes work through a gossipsub auction. OpenSwarm adds workload types the node can bid on and a second income path that needs no auction at all:

Role Work Paid by
Storage Pin an ipfile swarm for a period, seed it Job price (pinning) plus vouchers per byte served
Relay Fan out iplive segments to viewers Vouchers per byte served
Transcode Produce ipaudio / ipvideo renditions, publish them as ipfile swarms Job price
Index Replicate ipdb feeds, answer queries, serve a gateway Job price plus x402 per query
Keeper Hold a file's content key and grant it to paying peers Share of each key grant

Details, thirteen worked use cases and the proposed CLI invocations are in c0mpute.md.

What it defines

One swarm shape. A hybrid BEP 52 torrent whose single payload file is AES-256-CTR ciphertext. The v1 infohash makes it reachable from WebTorrent in a browser, the v2 merkle tree makes every 16 KiB block verifiable, and the plaintext root in the signed manifest makes the decrypted result verifiable.

One key model. A publisher key pair (Ed25519). Adding a file mints a per-file pair derived from it: the public half is the file's identity and the BEP 46 key under which the latest manifest is published; the private half signs the manifest and authorises key grants and payout changes. A separate random content key encrypts the bytes and is wrapped to paying peers.

One payment loop. A leecher buys a pass (x402, USDC, CoinPay as the reference hub). A seeder serves pieces inside a bounded credit window. After verifying each piece the leecher signs a cumulative voucher. The seeder redeems the latest voucher at the hub, which splits it between seeder, publisher and hub. Nobody pays for bytes they did not verify, and nobody serves more than the window unpaid.

One catalogue. An ipdb feed is a signed, hash-linked log of records. Its head is a BEP 44 mutable item under the feed key, so any DHT node can find the latest catalogue of any publisher with one get.

One seed market. A pay2seed offer is money escrowed at a hub for a swarm to be kept for a period, public or private, and it cannot be listed without a signed attestation of who put the data there and on what basis. Seeders take leases, prove they hold and serve the pieces every period, and are paid per GiB-month. It is how a torrent client becomes a legitimate file sharer: consent on the way in, proof on the way out, and a payout for staying.

What it does not define

A media player. Transcoding settings beyond what a manifest must declare. A token. A blockchain. Content moderation. A search ranking. DRM in the sense of controlling a device after the key is delivered; a paying peer holds the key and the spec says so.

What already exists

Piece Where Relationship
Browser WebTorrent player, hybrid Node seeder, wss trackers profullstack/media-streamer (bittorrented.com) Speaks the vanilla wire this family extends; needs the ipfile extension to pay
DHT crawl (bitmagnet) and /dht browse profullstack/media-streamer, dht-infohash-crawler Observes ipfile swarms as opaque infohashes; ipdb is how it would learn what they are
Pay-per-pass grants, HLS manifest sealing media-streamer IPTV and seedbox rails The central-proxy version of what ippay moves into the swarm
Headless seeder daemon with an add API and per-torrent seed time torlink (torlnk serve) The pay2seed seeder client, once it polls a market and answers challenges
x402 v2 offer, X-PAYMENT proof, verify and settle profullstack/x402-gateway, CoinPay ippay pass purchase reuses it unchanged
CloudEvents 1.0 + Standard Webhooks signing profullstack/autoblog Every OpenSwarm event uses the same envelope and headers
MTP/1 post-quantum transport, name pins profullstack/moshpit-transport, moshpit-proxy Optional tunnel for native peer links; ipname pin kind
blake3 chunk store, RS 10/14 erasure, ffmpeg transcode, live-stream DIP 0019 profullstack/c0mpute The node that seeds, relays, transcodes and indexes

New in this family: the extension messages, the manifest and key model, the pass and voucher protocol, the catalogue log, and the media record types.

Quick start (proposed CLI)

# One publisher identity, reused for every file
ip init

# Add a file: derives the file key pair, encrypts, builds the hybrid torrent,
# signs the manifest, starts seeding
ip file add ./interview.flac --per-gib 0.01 --key-price 0.50

# Publish an audio release that references it
ip audio publish ./release.json

# Fetch as a paying peer (buys a pass, gets the key, verifies, decrypts)
ip file get ed25519:0d87e09c7fea3ad6ba6c2f3e027ea47f5b245452899910948470906704c5295d --out ./interview.flac

# Ask the catalogue
ip db query --type ipaudio.track --where 'record.artist == "Ada"' --limit 20

Relationship to the other LogicSRC specs

  • OpenCreds (opencreds.md) stores the publisher seed as a key item. Losing that seed is the one unrecoverable event in this family, and OpenCreds is where it should live.
  • OpenContext (opencontext.md) governs what an agent may read. An agent holding a pass for one swarm is entitled to that swarm's key and nothing else; the pass scope is the OpenContext decision.
  • OpenOntology (openontology.md) names the entities an ipdb entry refers to. An ipaudio.track's artist is an ontology entity where one is in use.
  • Credential Sharing (credential-sharing.md) moves a hub API key or a payout address between providers; OpenSwarm never stores either.